Home Play by Mail Friendly fire: Ciattarelli’s Brennan strategy, and reproductive freedom gives way to self-defense.

Friendly fire: Ciattarelli’s Brennan strategy, and reproductive freedom gives way to self-defense.


Can Americans still have a sensible and friendly political discussion across the partisan divide? The answer is yes, and we intend to prove it. Julie roginsky, a democrat and Mike DuHaime, a Republican, are consultants who have worked on opposing teams throughout their careers but remained friends throughout. Here they discuss the Editor of the Weekly Events Editorial Page Tom moran.

Q. The United States Supreme Court has refused to stop a new Texas law that bans all abortions after six weeks, with no exceptions for rape or incest, a decision which Judge Sonia Sotomayor called “astonishing. In his dissent. Roe v. Wade will likely be on the agenda for the next term. Is this the end of the road for the national guarantee of the right to abortion?

Julie: Roe v. Wade did die, killed by five judges – including four men – who delivered an unsigned opinion in the middle of the night without holding a single hearing. Thanks to them, a woman in Texas who is more than six weeks pregnant is prohibited from having an abortion. And not just women – young girls raped by their fathers cannot terminate their pregnancy. Six weeks might as well be six seconds. As most women who have been pregnant know, an obstetrician will usually tell a patient who thinks she might be pregnant to schedule a visit at least eight weeks after her last period. Genetic testing is done well after six weeks of pregnancy. This court requires women to carry to term, even if they have known for the last two trimesters that the fetus is not viable or severely disabled. Once again, men have deprived women of all power over their bodies and their lives.

Mike: I believe we should encourage a culture that values ​​life and reduces the number of abortions. But this Texas law is not the way to go. In cases of rape and incest, even most pro-life people make exceptions for this. Democrats are likely to act in a legislative fashion at the federal level and will certainly have a new campaign problem that will distract attention from Afghanistan.

Q. The law innovates in its mode of application. It bars state officials from intervening and instead charges private citizens to enforce the restrictions through civil lawsuits against doctors, clinics and even someone driving a woman to a clinic. What is the significance of this?

Julie: We have legalized self-defense. The next time your girlfriend dumps you you can report her and the friend who drove her to the clinic for terminating a pregnancy and even if you make it up, she and the friend will have to go through the hassle. and the expense of defending oneself. . If she actually ended her pregnancy only seven weeks later (when many women find out they are first pregnant), you can collect a premium of $ 10,000, plus legal fees.

Julie: An Uber driver will now have to ask any woman he drops off if he takes her for an abortion, lest he be harassed by someone trying to hurt him. It’s a dystopian nightmare, better suited to 1930s Russia than 21st century Texas.

Mike: As I said, this goes too far, will face a backlash and not have the desired effect of those who passed the bill.

Q. In his national speech on Afghanistan, President Biden called the evacuation of 125,000 people from Kabul “an extraordinary success.” Will Americans come to see it that way? Will this episode damage Biden’s position in the long run?

Julie: We need to get the same people who got us into this cable TV mess – or, at the very least, list their consulting contracts with companies that profited from the continuing war in Afghanistan. The reality is that the United States has evacuated over 100,000 people from Kabul under appalling circumstances. My deep regret is that we have not accepted many more refugees, especially those who remain in danger.

Mike: Just because the military acted heroically and professionally in the incredible job they did in the evacuation, doesn’t mean Joe Biden did a good job. He did a terrible job. He set his timeline based on his own PR motive to get him out on 9/11 and, worse yet, to support an Afghan government’s desire to retain its front credibility, for a government that has given up. first day. Biden will have a hard time getting over it. People will see it as more than a foreign policy decision; it will be seen as a broader jurisdictional issue.

Q. New data shows New Jersey has only recovered 62% of the jobs lost during the pandemic, putting us near the bottom, and our unemployment rate of 7.3% remains well above the national average of 5. , 4%. Do you see a sign that is hurting Gov. Phil Murphy in his bid for re-election?

Julie: I suspect this will be something Republicans start to hammer out now. On the flip side, the mail-in ballots go out in about two weeks, so it’s getting late for it to stick to Governor Murphy.

Mike: This should absolutely be an issue in the campaign. Republicans win in the NJ when it comes to a referendum on a failed economy. Ciattarelli will definitely hammer that out. Note the challenger victories of Governor Whitman and Governor Christie. Republicans should welcome this debate.

Q. As schools open next week, Murphy and the business community are hoping that a wave of parents will return to work, which will boost the economy. At the same time, 500,000 households will lose unemployment benefits which have injected around $ 1.2 billion into the state’s economy each month. How do you want it to be?

Julie: There is no way parents will go back to work and we will restart the economy if schools close again. This is why I am puzzled that there is no vaccine mandate for all teachers and students over 12 years old. As I have said many times, Governor Murphy is expected to be fine in November because voters believe he has done a good job in dealing with the pandemic. But this can quickly change if the school situation is not back under control. I speak as a mother – if my son has to stay at home again because irresponsible adults will not protect themselves and those who are too young for the vaccine, I will not return to the office. I’ll be home, making sure he doesn’t set the toaster on fire and home schooling him, because distance learning alone isn’t enough. It’s not good for anyone – the economy, productivity, the kids or the politicians who won’t do all they humanly can to prevent this catastrophe from happening.

Mike: Julie is there. One of the big variables in the governor’s race is in-person schooling. Any closure or massive epidemic will have political consequences.

Q. Jack Ciattarelli, the GOP gubernatorial candidate, has said he will not be removing the ad featuring Katie Brennan, who accused her of being raped by a senior campaign executive Murphy, despite its objections to its use. Smart moving?

Julie: Katie Brennan and the other survivors shouldn’t have to relive their trauma, but this is not how our society works. This is why so many women are reluctant to come forward, especially when the wrongdoing involves prominent men. The stories of Christine Blasey Ford and Anita Hill were also used to score political points in the 2018 and 1992 campaigns, respectively. (I say this as someone who had to watch a Hollywood movie that depicted a very difficult time in my life without asking for my consent – all because I had filed a sexual harassment complaint against a very famous man. ) But if you ask if this is a smart move from a purely political standpoint, even having this debate over whether Ciattarelli was right to use the image of Katie in an ad only helps his campaign because it refocuses attention on his allegations against Governor Murphy – which is why the Murphy campaign has been wise to decline to comment and further amplify the underlying message.

Mike: From a political point of view, it is quite a fair game. An explosive allegation, made publicly, is now part of the public record. There was no way this case would not be used in this campaign by Ciattarelli. I’m sure no one on Jack’s team wants Brennan to be hurt by this, but they’d say they weren’t the one causing this problem.

Our journalism needs your support. Please subscribe today To NJ.com.

Bookmark NJ.com/Opinion. Follow on Twitter @NJ_Opinion and find NJ.com Facebook Reviews.

Tell us your coronavirus storieswhether it’s a hot tip, a topic you want us to cover, or a personal story you want to share.

If you want updates on New Jersey specific coronavirus news, subscribe to our Coronavirus in NJ newsletter.